172. Kenya 5: on corruption and a crooked election

beach-crafts-kenya-august-2007.jpg‘Say No to Corruption,’ read the badge on the immigration officer’s sleeve at Mombasa airport. Drawing our attention to the issue, right from the moment when we entered the country.

Kenya’s president from 1978 to 2002, Daniel arap Moi, was widely detested for corruption and political oppression. During his term, Kenya slipped from the 133rd to the 155th country in the world in economic prosperity. There might not be that many more countries.

Moi’s successor, Mwai Kibaki, was elected on an anti-corruption ticket – hence the badge campaign in Mombasa. But when I asked Kenyans during our visit what they thought of Kibaki – they were unanimous. ‘He’s the same as all the others,’ they said. ‘Corrupt, just like the rest of them.’

Yesterday’s declaration of Kibaki as victor in the Kenyan elections, despite a string of exit polls indicating firmly that he had lost to Raila Odinga, serves only to confirm that view.

Corruption. It might be Africa’s biggest problem. Certainly it’s the one trotted out by people who don’t want to help the continent. ‘There’s no point giving money, or aid,’ they say. ‘It’s unlikely to end up with those who need it.’

But this trip, I began to understand corruption, just a little. Not the kind of barefaced electoral swindle which threatens the whole practice of democracy, but rather the day-to-day variety. The siphoning off the top of just a little, and then more and more goods and money, so that finally they don’t arrive at all.

Why do people do it, and how can they so mindlessly deprive the needy ? That’s something I’d never come close to comprehending before.

masai-chilldren-kenya-august-2007.jpg It started soon after we arrived at our hotel. We started making enquiries to find an orphanage in the area. ‘We’ve brought some things for the children there,’ we explained. ‘And we’d like to take our children, to see for themselves.’

The news got around. Guests in the hotel who had things to give away. A quiet word from the waiter. A tactful suggestion from the lady at the pool. An outright request from the taxi driver, when we arranged our ride to the orphanage.

‘If you’ve brought some things with you, then please give them to me. Because my kids are starving.’

At first I found it shocking. Cynical. Appalling, even. Just imagine, if you were taking a bag of old clothes and toys to the charity shop at home, and someone asked you if they could rifle through it first. It would simply never happen.

But the more I dissected it, the more I realised that’s just how it was. Yes, these people had jobs, but they didn’t earn much. The hotel didn’t always pay them on time, and sometimes it didn’t pay at all. They dared not complain, for fear of being sacked on the spot. Such is the labour market, when there are millions unemployed and millions more starving. The hotel staff were all desperately thin, and desperately doing their best to feed their families on very little. The whole village was living from hand to mouth, and from day to day.

For the taxi driver, it was harder still. He came from Malindi, half an hour up the coast, and he had three kids of his own to look after, and two more he’d taken in from sick relatives, too. He had absolutely no money – I had to pay him at the start of every journey, so that he could buy petrol on the way out of town. His financial arrangements didn’t even run to purchasing fuel for his taxi.

And when he asked for our help, it wasn’t that easy to decline. Because those kids in the orphanage – in material terms, they were luckier than most. They had food on the table, and a roof over their heads. They had health care, and schooling, and clean water, and beds and mosquito nets. They wanted for little, except a parent of their own.

kenya-children-the-future-2008.jpgSo we gave our taxi driver a few children’s clothes from our cache. And we found toys for the twin girls of the lady by the pool, too – it was no trouble to us, since we weren’t taking any of those things home.

But that series of events – it set me thinking. It wasn’t the existence of such poverty. It was the nature of it, and the scale.

Slowly it dawned that the social rules that we live by – well, they might not work here. When everyone around you is starving, the niceties of tact are irrelevant. Because, yes, the orphanage kids need assistance, but you might need it more.

And in a second, I could see life here quite differently. European or American values didn’t apply so straightforwardly where existence was a raw and Darwinian struggle for survival. You had to ask for what you could get, and you had to get it somehow.

Suddenly, the whole issue of corruption began to make more sense. Which is the more important human right ? A man’s right to property, or his neighbour’s to life ? In our world, that choice rarely arises. But in vast parts of Africa, it’s a question of life or death every day. If a man has money which he can live without, and which you need to survive, then the reasons for taking it become much clearer to see.

I’d never condone it, but I could begin to understand it, for the very first time.

To keep body and soul together, then at a certain level, any ruse will do. And if you do survive, even then there are no guarantees that will continue. You have to keep on eating, and keep on acquiring, to distance yourself further from the abyss. And so corruption and theft continues long after it’s a mortal question.

In that world and in that culture, that’s just what people do, and how the moral realities apply. And for ministers and government officials, with the status and financial benefits which are offered to them, the temptation to hang on to power and the wealth that goes with it might be even more compelling.

In Africa, that adage is true. The man stole the money, but society was to blame.

To change that culture, Africa needs much more than anti-corruption laws and enforcement. We have to alleviate the hardship and suffering which lie at the root of this crime in the first place. Money is even more desperately needed if it might not all get through. Because in the long run, kindness is the only cure.

dhow-crew-kenya-august-2007.jpgAnd whilst that struggle for survival continues, there’ll be no lasting salvation for those people, and that society will always hang on the brink of decay.

Into dicatorship, anarchy and bloodshed. Exactly as we’ve seen in Kenya today.

https://roadsofstone.com/2007/12/31/172-kenya-5-on-corruption-and-a-crooked-election/ : : https://roadsofstone.com/2007/12/31/172-kenya-5-on-corruption-and-a-crooked-election/ : : https://roadsofstone.com/2007/12/31/172-kenya-5-on-corruption-and-a-crooked-election/ : : del.icio.us:https://roadsofstone.com/2007/12/31/172-kenya-5-on-corruption-and-a-crooked-election/ : : https://roadsofstone.com/2007/12/31/172-kenya-5-on-corruption-and-a-crooked-election/ : : https://roadsofstone.com/2007/12/31/172-kenya-5-on-corruption-and-a-crooked-election/

Related articles:
168. Kenya 4: on the orphanage, and AIDS
164. Kenya 2: The dusk behind the beach
161. Kenya 1: The road to Mombasa
124. Exploring Africa with Bono
166. Kenya 3: Masai Mara – the last wilderness

14 responses to “172. Kenya 5: on corruption and a crooked election

  1. Interesting and very true reflections on the realities of life in Africa. But what is hard to understand is the collusion in kleptocracy at the top.

    Happy New Year

  2. Kleptocracy. Now there’s a word which describes it well – many thanks, Wombats.

    Like you, I have struggled to see why corruption so often extends to the top. A pragmatic approach to property might be understandable when you’re starving, but the government ministers are hardly that.

    My point is that it’s surely a cultural thing. If life is raw and dangerous, then those attitudes will inevitably permeate all sections of society and become ingrained as behaviours at every level.

    If you spend your youth looking desperately for every meal, then in adulthood it will be hard to stop taking just whatever you can get, even when the risks of starvation have receded.

    And it’s also true, in the Dawkinisian struggles of Africa, that the more you have, the greater the chances of your and your family’s health and survival.

    I’d be very interested in your own ideas, Wombats, from your long experience of aid and charity work, on exactly how those organisations can and should best approach the problem, to ensure that the aid really does get through.

  3. More information and photographs of the troubles in Kenya can be found at Insight Kenya.

    This is the state of democracy in Kenya.
    Shocking images from the election’s aftermath.

    Bodies pile up in Nairobi.

    We feel cheated say Raila’s supporters.

  4. Here’s some more analysis from African Path.

    Kenya Elections: What Really Happened, Part 1.

    Kenya Elections: What Really Happened, Part 2.

    And there’s much more detail than in the international media so far.

  5. Too bad to say that the #1 cause of hunger and staration in every nation worldwide is corruption of just a few politicians who take advantage of their power instead of protecting the rights of their people.

    And in the end it is the poor little children who always suffer most as a result …

  6. Thank you, Rhosie. And you may well be right, at that.

  7. Interesting.
    Might find this link useful:

    I read Chinua Achebe years ago, and it shifted my perspective. Another insightful author is J.M. Coetze, his ‘Waiting for the Barbarians’ is a classic …

  8. Welcome to Roads of Stone, canadada, and thank you for the link – a really fascinating resource devoted to African literature.

    That’s a very interesting blog you’ve got there, too. I’m looking forward to exploring more.

    Thanks for your visit, and for your input. I’ll hope to see you back again here soon.

  9. You will.

    Looked briefly at your New Writing Project.
    That one takes ‘guts’.

    You might enjoy F.H.B. (another short story) on my site.

    Will be back. Cheers, c

  10. That’s an excellent short story, canadada.

    Funerals are often a good craic. There might not be as much dancing as at weddings, but there is often better conversation. The reflective atmosphere can bring people out of themselves.

    Unfortunately, there have been a lot too many funerals in Kenya recently. Let’s hope the situation there improves.

    I think everyone there recognises that it has to, or else there’s a risk of some of the same problems occurring as in Zimbabwe, or Rwanda.

  11. Thank you kindly.

    Kenya is tragic. ‘Angry young men’ running riot gangland style has never accomplished much of anything except breed fear and loathing. On the other hand, oppressive/subjugating dictatorial military regimes don’t accomplish much of anything either, except breed systemic corrupting distrust and generational anger, with equal gobs of fear and loathing.

    Kenya’s current power struggle is acute. Does either ‘side’ offer any kind of comprehensive integrated ‘plan’ for Kenya’s FUTURE? It doesn’t appear so. One wonders if they actually have the capacity to retain ‘nation state’ status. As long as ‘brother kills brother’ there seems little likelihood of reconciliation and/or resolution. For now, their respective chest thumping mantras remain the same, “Every dog has their day – Hoorah!”.

    I don’t know that the international ‘media’ frenzy/coverage is actually ‘helping’ the situation either. Nothing generates brazen stupid acts of machismo faster than ‘being on T.V’. , ‘heard on the radio’, or ‘printed in the press’, locally and globally. It is a false form, the worst form, of ‘instant status’ and ‘celebritydom’. It fuels the ‘fire’.

    One can only hope that perhaps ‘the situation’ will create an opportunity for a genuine LEADER of the NATIONAL TRIBE of KENYA to advance forward through the many tears and horrific bloodshed …

    Nation States evolve.
    And growing pains hurt.

  12. Thank you, Canadada, for your insight.

    I’d agree with you that there are two sides to every argument, and that peace and preventing bloodshed are top priority.

    In this case, though, we have an established and relatively stable democracy which is inclined to shift direction, and one side which is determinedly and fraudulently preventing that occurring, whilst beating up the opposition.

    Whilst most power struggles call for dialogue in the search for common ground, it’s hard to find scope for mutual understanding whilst such basic principles are being trampled over and cut down with machetes.

    In the scale of righteous protest, Odinga’s followers have been relatively reserved, up to now.

  13. …. whilst … ? what a lovely word … it’s so … so …
    British !!

    Men have fought for ‘territory’ since time immemorial . That basic posture doesn’t seem likely to change anytime soon … Unfortunately, everyone gets caught up in their madness too. Machete meets machete and blood flows. No easy solution here as far as I can SEE.

  14. Well, C, I’m not sure it’s about territory. I think it’s about power (and hence corruption and money) in this case.

    Anyway, it’s timely that you mention Kenya. There seems to be good news, about a peace of sorts between Kibaki and Odinga. Let’s hope it lasts.

    Meanwhile, tourism in Kenya has taken a huge hit these past few months. I’m going to return to the subject of Kenya soon, to outline some simple things that tourists and every one of us can do to help the plight of Africa.

Leave a Reply to Roads Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s